Nu-Wood Window Trim

There are only a few (expensive) options for custom window trim...the best option that I found is made by Nu-Wood.  They are based out of Jasper, Indiana and can be found online at http://www.nuwood.com/

We ordered our window headers and sills from them.  They are a urethane product, so they are lightweight and won't rust, rot, etc.  And, they are easily painted.  They come in a standard white primer color so we went over them with a gloss white to match our other trim.  These pictures don't do them justice since I took them in our dark garage...actually, they look really good.  I'll get some more pictures of them installed on the house next week. 

As you can see, the headers are a little over 7" tall, so they should give the house a somewhat more grand and old school look.  Expect to spend a few hundred dollars per window.  Your other options are to buy really expensive metal kits that are now sold by the window manufacturers or to have the trim milled on site.  The time and labor expense for that is pretty high.